SAVi Report

Thursday 22 October 2026 in SAF

Argus SAF Focus Day: Policymakers insist EU/UK reviews will not dilute ambition

Justine El Amrani-Joutey
Analyst at Ishka
justine@ishkaglobal.com

UK and EU policymakers sought to once more reassure investors of the stability of their respective SAF mandates at this week’s Argus Biofuels Europe conference in London, as airlines questioned the near-term availability of advanced SAF and producers warned that reconsidering sub-targets could undermine investment.

The discussions took place during the conference’s SAF Focus Day on 20th October, just weeks after the industry learned that EU fuel suppliers delivered 1.1 Mt of SAF in 2025 or 2.8%, comfortably surpassing ReFuelEU Aviation's 2% requirement in its first year of implementation.

Ishka Airfinance examines the main SAF supply takeaways from the one-day event. A second report will examine the demand side, looking at airline procurement, costs, and infrastructure access.

Policymakers insist that SAF policy adjustments will not dilute ambition

The European Commission's planned 2027 revision of ReFuelEU Aviation will address implementation difficulties rather than reconsider its targets, Jo Dardenne, a policy officer for aviation at the European Commission’s transport directorate-general (DG MOVE), told the delegates. Next year’s revision is “not about changing the ambition of the mandate, […] the direction is clear, and that will not change.” Among the “technical tweaks” under consideration are clarifications to anti-tankering exemptions, fuel documentation and enforcement penalties.

Dardenne noted that 11 member states have faced infringement proceedings for failing to establish the required penalty systems under ReFuelEU. Dardenne also let on, responding to an audience question, that the Commission was “open” to considering a more linear progression between ReFuelEU's mandate step increases, similar to the UK's approach, without changing the final targets.

The UK Department for Transport (DfT) was equally insistent that its June call for evidence did not signal a retreat from its SAF mandate. The consultation asks participants their thoughts on the availability of alternatives to HEFA, the feedstock-constrained waste oils-based pathway most common today, as a cap on eligible HEFA supply begins in 2027 and a separate power-to-liquid (PtL) advanced SAF obligation takes effect in 2028.

Clarissa Atlee, head of SAF mandate policy at DfT, said the government had no preferred option and expected to respond to the consultation before year-end, insisting that “this consultation process is really just about the short term”.

The UK policy manager for aviation and shipping at NGO Transport & Environment (T&E) Tom Taylor, warned that “even these conversations about how we can change policy frameworks that were set up to be long-term, two years into a mandate, are particularly damaging”, particularly to investment in domestic production.

Nova Pangaea Technologies' CCO Jonathan Wood, whose company is developing technology to convert agricultural and forestry residues into advanced ethanol for SAF production, was similarly critical of the UK consultation. “The very fact that we have this consultation going on has undermined investment confidence,” he said, distinguishing the UK exercise from the EU review, which had been scheduled when ReFuelEU was adopted.

Besides these potential hiccups, financial support for SAF production alongside the mandates is progressing. Members of the EU’s e-SAF Early Movers Coalition (Germany, Austria and Luxembourg) are preparing a €2.1 billion ($2.35 billion) double-sided auction for e-SAF. “That's quite significant, it's much more than what we thought would be delivered by the start of the coalition,” Dardenne insisted, confirming the scheme is expected to launch in 2027. She also confirmed that the Commission was studying the modalities for proposing an EU-wide double auction.

‘Europe could make many times more SAF than it does’

Whatever adjustments the UK and EU may be considering, their mandates have demonstrably stimulated SAF consumption. Argus senior analyst Louis Springate told delegates that the EU and UK used approximately four times as much SAF as the US in 2025, despite the latter's considerably larger aviation market.

He attributed the difference partly to the differing policy approaches, as US federal support has generally been available to both SAF and hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO), or renewable diesel. The two fuels can be produced from similar feedstocks in the same hydroprocessing facilities, but HVO generally offers higher yields and lower processing costs.

“A subsidy lets producers chase the easier product, a mandate doesn't give them that choice,” Springate concluded. Neste's head of public and regulatory affairs for EMEA, Samuel Maubanc, also credited the EU's policies with supporting investment in SAF capacity, arguing that “the supply [sector] has done the homework, so the fuels are there.”

Neste, the world’s largest renewable fuel producer, expects its global SAF production capability to increase from 1.5 Mt to 2.2 Mt annually following its Rotterdam expansion in 2027. Yet, the amount of HEFA capacity actually used to produce SAF remains sensitive to the relative profitability of aviation fuel and renewable diesel. “On paper, Europe could make many times more SAF than it does, but most of that capacity comes out as HVO,” Springate explains, warning of potential supply complexities even in the short term.

E-SAF supply getting ‘lost in the uncertainties’

The EU's synthetic-fuel obligation requires e-SAF to account for 1.2% of aviation fuel supplied from 2030 – a sub-target to the EU’s 6% SAF mandate – yet no large-scale e-SAF facility in the EU has yet reached final investment decision (FID). Amid this shortage of investment, which has become both an argument for relaxing the requirement and is a potential consequence of questioning it, ING's director of energy sector coverage, Menzo Reinders, warned that “the next 6-12 months will be critical” for pre-FID e-SAF projects intending to deliver fuel by 2030.

Offering an e-SAF FID example beyond Europe was Blair Phelan, managing director of Phelan Green Group. His company “were able to take the decision on what we think is going to happen in the future rather than getting lost in all of the uncertainties,” and announced in September FID for the first phase of its Saldanha Bay e-SAF project in South Africa, with $100 million in equity committed and the International Finance Corporation (IFC) acting as lead arranger for debt financing. Phelan told delegates the debt financial close was targeted for February 2027, construction start for Q1 2027, and first EU and UK deliveries for mid-2029. The initial facility would produce 35,000 tonnes annually, increasing to 70 000 tonnes by 2032 and, eventually, 140 000 tonnes per annum at full capacity.

Phelan nevertheless acknowledged the challenge of achieving competitive costs at this scale, as the initial facility will require substantial renewable energy generation, hydrogen and fuel-synthesis infrastructure relative to its output. He believed that larger plants and improved batteries would eventually offer greater scope for cost reductions.

Looking at potential European production, Alvaro Macarro, director of sustainable aviation at Moeve (formerly Cepsa), described progress in Europe on green hydrogen production, a core feedstock for e-SAF. At the Andalusian Green Hydrogen Valley, construction began in September on the first phase (300 MW of electrolyser capacity) of a larger €1 billion ($1.12 billion) investment.

Macarro, whose firm Moeve also refines conventional jet fuel, believes imports will be needed to meet the EU’s 2030 e-SAF sub-target, but nevertheless opposed postponing it.

The Ishka Airfinance View

Europe's SAF mandates have created an attractive market for overseas producers, offering certainty of demand and higher prices than in other regions. According to Argus, Chinese SAF exports to Europe increased from 17,000 tonnes in 2024 to more than 600,000 tonnes so far in 2026, helped by the exclusion of SAF from EU anti-dumping duties on Chinese biodiesel and HVO.

On the sidelines of the conference, a prospective Indian HEFA producer also spoke enthusiastically to Ishka Airfinance about the margins available from supplying Europe. Asked about e-SAF, however, they said they were “leaving that to the Europeans”, citing high costs and unproven technologies. The interest of overseas producers in Europe's HEFA SAF market raises questions about where European producers could establish a competitive advantage without depending on imported waste feedstocks. The UK's HEFA cap and the EU's e-SAF sub-mandate create those opportunities. The investment decisions taken over the next 12 months should provide a clearer picture.

Tags: E-Fuel / E-Kerosene / PtL / Electrofuel / RFNBO, HEFA, SAF feedstocks, SAF Production

Supporting you on the journey to Net Zero