This is a joint article by Omar Nuruzade, Co-Founder and CEO of Nexus Lab, Rob Neale, Chief Product Officer and founder of PACE, part of RDC Aviation, and Eduardo Mariz, Senior Analyst and Sustainability Lead at Ishka Airfinance.
The climate-warming effect of aircraft contrails has evolved from a sidelined conversation to a broadly acknowledged area for urgent action, with policy-shaping implications for airlines, flight dispatchers, air traffic control, and countries at large. Contrails are among the largest non-CO₂ climate impacts of any hard-to-abate sector, and without them, aviation’s climate footprint remains significantly underrepresented.
They are also, at least in principle, more readily addressable than CO₂ emissions, and are moving rapidly towards systematic measurement through government-mandated mechanisms in Europe. As a result, we may be only a few years – or perhaps less – away from contrails entering the mainstream of aviation climate reporting.
In that context, what should aviation finance do about them? This joint article by Nexus Lab, PACE, and Ishka Airfinance explores the implications for aviation financiers and makes the case for greater understanding.
The problem with CO2 intensity
Aviation finance’s environmental calculus runs on one number: CO2 intensity. It's clean, it's comparable, but it's missing most of the picture.
Non-CO2 effects don't just add to aviation's climate impact. Research backed by EASA and the European Commission puts non-CO2 effects at 66% of aviation's net climate forcing in 2018, more than CO2 itself. For an industry that finances aircraft for 20 to 30 years and underwrites billions in aviation risk, it isn't a scientific footnote. It's an exposure sitting outside almost every credit model, ESG score and underwriting decision being made today.
It is also a unique situation. Some non-CO₂ climate impacts are underreported in other hard-to-abate sectors, but nothing to the same level of magnitude. Take Arctic black carbon in shipping as an example – the fine soot derived from fuel combustion that blackens Arctic snow and ice and accelerates melting. It may also be rarely accounted for, but the IMO's 2018 emissions inventory estimates black carbon at around 6.85% of shipping's CO₂-equivalent emissions, compared with 91.32% for CO₂.
For aviation, not only is the climate warming contribution several times larger, but it is increasingly easier to measure – both scientifically and commercially for fleets and portfolios. The excuse that contrails are too hard to measure is largely expiring; and Europe is the reason why.
The science just became a regulatory signal
Since January 2025, airlines have had to start monitoring and reporting non-CO2 effects under the EU ETS, initially for intra-European flights. From 2027, that reporting requirement automatically expands to all flights arriving and departing Europe, pulling long-haul operations into scope for the first time, including flights over the contrail-prone North Atlantic.
This summer, the European Commission went further. Its proposed ETS revision sets aside up to 3 million ETS emissions allowances through 2033 (capped at 420,000 a year), specifically to reward airlines that build contrail forecasting into flight planning and act on it operationally. The incentive will sit alongside a broader, extended support mechanism running to 2040 that already covers airlines’ SAF price premium on a first-come, first-served basis.
Regulators have stopped asking whether non-CO2 climate impacts are real. They're now requiring airlines to report them and encouraging them to take avoidance action. That will inevitably push non-CO₂ impacts into mainstream climate reporting. As airlines begin measuring them consistently, they will become comparable across peers, trackable over time and, crucially, actionable.
Eventually, action on contrails could also be a cost-saver. In 2027, the Commission will decide whether to make a legislative proposal to price the non-CO2 effects of aviation under the EU ETS.
This is a shift aviation financiers can't afford to miss.
The exposure sitting inside every bank's aviation book
Most banks size up airline climate performance on fuel efficiency and CO2 intensity, but two airlines with near-identical CO2 profiles could carry very different non-CO2 exposure. It depends on network, geography, cruising altitude, time of day, weather, aircraft type, engine type and how the airline actually operates and none of that shows up in a CO2 comparison.
A financing decision made in 2026 isn't just underwriting today's rulebook. It's underwriting an asset that may still be flying in the 2040s, so a book that looks well-diversified on CO2 terms today could look concentrated on a broader climate-risk basis tomorrow.
The questions worth putting to an aviation portfolio now:
- How exposed is this airline's network to routes and conditions prone to persistent, warming contrails?
- Are we using CO2 intensity as a stand-in for total climate risk? How much longer does that assumption hold?
- If non-CO2 becomes a cost line for airlines, what does that do to residual values, credit quality or covenant headroom on longer-term deals?
- Could differences in engine technology materially affect the non-CO2 exposure of aircraft in my portfolio?
- Could our aviation portfolio be more / or less exposed than a CO2-only view suggests?
The exposure sitting inside every underwriter's book
For aviation underwriters, the gap is arguably sharper. Environmental, liability and reinsurance pricing has historically leaned on the same CO2-based ESG scores and historical loss data, which was built for a world where CO2 was the whole climate story.
As non-CO2 reporting becomes standardised and mandatory across Europe, the distance between an airline's disclosed carbon footprint and its full climate impact stops being a scientific uncertainty and starts becoming a disclosure and liability question.
Same aircraft, same route, wildly different risk
Contrails don't behave like CO2. CO2 tracks fuel burn in a straight whereas contrail impact swings dramatically with atmospheric conditions. The same aircraft, on the same route, on the same day, can produce a heavily warming contrail on the outbound leg and almost nothing on the return leg.
That cuts two ways for finance. First, it rules out generic assumptions. No airline, aircraft type or route can fairly be labelled “high-risk”. Second, and more usefully, it means the exposure is concentrated rather than universal. Airlines may not need to overhaul entire operations; they may only need to manage a relatively small number of high-impact flights. That reframes the question about how much of this exposure is manageable, and how much managing it costs? That is a question that financiers and underwriters can now put a number on.
The move now isn't to price it; it's to understand it
None of this means non-CO2 is about to land on a balance sheet as a formal liability overnight and treating it that way would overstate where the science and the regulation currently sit, but the direction of travel is unambiguous. Mandatory reporting, maturing forecasting models, airline operational trials (such as the one recently launched by a Google and UK government-backed consortium), and now EU ETS allowances tied directly to contrail management.
Institutions that get ahead of it gain two things: a head start on a genuinely new dimension of aviation risk, and possibly good news if a portfolio turns out to be less exposed than feared. Either way, that's information worth having before an investor asks the question first, or, perhaps eventually, an airline incurs higher opex exposures from EU ETS pricing.
The first step isn't pricing the risk. It's understanding it — before the market prices it for you.
Next: we take this out of the abstract with an upcoming case study using real transatlantic flights — same airline, same route, similar aircraft, different days and departure times — we'll show how far CO2 and non-CO2 impact actually diverge, what drives the variation, and what avoiding it would really cost.
Omar Nuruzade is Co-Founder and CEO of Nexus Lab, a contrail-reduction software company founded in 2022 with a clear goal: to mitigate the greenhouse effect and promote a more sustainable future.
Rob Neale is Chief Product Officer and founder of PACE, part of RDC Aviation, a software and ESG analytics platform focused on aviation CO2 emissions reduction.
Eduardo Mariz is Senior Analyst and Sustainability Lead at Ishka Airfinance.