European mandates have materially increased SAF consumption, but questions remain around who should bear the additional costs, how emerging producers can secure long-term offtake agreements, or whether existing distribution arrangements allow independent suppliers to compete. All three issues featured at the Argus Biofuels Europe conference’s SAF Focus Day on 20th October, where airlines challenged both the prices charged by fuel suppliers and restrictions on procuring SAF directly.
Ishka Airfinance examines the demand-side takeaways from the one-day event. For supply-side takeaways, see this earlier report.
SAF pricing comes under scrutiny
Despite some recent easing, SAF remains considerably more expensive than conventional jet fuel. According to Argus, the event organiser and a price-reporting agency, Europe paid approximately 2.6 times as much for SAF as for conventional jet fuel in 2025. Its assessments show that HEFA SAF reached around $2,600-$2,700 per tonne in October 2025, compared with approximately $2,300 per tonne by mid-October 2026.
Consequently, the premium over conventional jet fuel in northwest Europe fell particularly sharply in recent weeks, from around $1,200 per tonne in early September to approximately $750 per tonne by mid-October, its lowest since Argus began assessing the differential in 2020. Argus attributed the decline partly to seasonal weakening in SAF demand as obligated suppliers approached fulfilment of their annual 2% requirements, while conventional jet-fuel prices remained elevated amidst the war in the Middle East.
It is worth noting, however, that SAF prices followed a different pattern last year, as suppliers rushed to meet annual targets with back-end-loaded demand.
Airlines purchasing SAF voluntarily outside of Europe are also encountering the pricing expectations established in obligated markets. Cathay Pacific's SAF procurement and investment manager Hala Ghanem observed that much of the global SAF production capacity is being directed towards the EU and UK mandated markets, where suppliers priced SAF with reference to non-compliance penalties.
European airlines have also criticised this tendency, which has seen suppliers – the obligated parties – allegedly pass on the cost of potential non-compliance to them. In May 2025, IATA estimated that ReFuelEU compliance surcharges averaged $54 per tonne of 2%-SAF-blended jet fuel purchased, whereas the SAF premium at the time would only have implied an additional $22 per tonne.
“[As a result,] there is only residual volume for us who want to procure for our voluntary [SAF] programmes […] it should not work like that,” Ghanem told delegates. Hong Kong’s Five-Year Plan contains a target to achieve SAF consumption of 1% to 3% in 2030, but, for now, no SAF requirement has been legislated.
ABRA Group's chief corporate responsibility officer Maria Whittaker also questioned benchmarking SAF against conventional jet fuel altogether, arguing that prices should instead reflect feedstock costs and carbon intensity. Sumitomo Corporation's associate director for SAF and biofuels, Leo Sakaguchi, also said the Japanese trading house was exploring feedstock-based pricing for long-term SAF offtake agreements, potentially using underlying commodities such as soybean oil as a reference instead of conventional jet fuel.
‘Can all airlines be offtakers? Absolutely no’
Europe’s mandates have helped spur investment in SAF projects worldwide, but whether the demand they generate is sufficiently reliable to underpin bankable investments remains an open question. “A demand mandate does not create bankable demand,” Whittaker argued. “Bankable demand comes when the risk is shared.”
Finnair VP of sustainability, Riku Aho, nevertheless saw a role for airlines to voluntarily support advanced bio-SAF and e-SAF projects, which “really seem to require the offtakes in order to get off the ground. But clearly, we can't be the only party.”
Even where airlines are willing to contract directly, committing to fuel from a facility that has yet to be built requires years of exposure to uncertain prices and policy incentives. Providing an investment-grade airline perspective, IAG's VP for SAF in the UK and Ireland, Olan Ryan, stressed the working capital, creditworthiness, and market access needed to support long-term take-or-pay obligations. “Can all airlines be offtakers? Absolutely no,” he said.
For business aviation firm VistaJet, the fuel price volatility of 2026 made seeking board approval for a 10-year agreement “probably not the best year to do it”, according to its director of sustainability, Andrew Thomas. Existing supplier relationships had instead secured provided VistaJet with “better pricing, increased quantities.” The carrier “could have a 10-year agreement” he explained but “it may not materialise”.
An airline capable of offtaking SAF is American Airlines, which has signed at least nine SAF deals since 2021, when Ishka Airfinance started tracking publicly announced SAF offtakes. Yet its managing director of fuel management, Ying Xu Mathis, acknowledged that time-limited US state incentives complicated long-term commitments. “A lot of times, it's first come, first served, so we've got to rush in and just grab an incentive,” she said. “It's hard for airlines to commit to a longer-term offtake because we don't know how long those incentives will be there.”
American Airlines has successfully tapped corporate demand for SAF Scope 3 certificates to offset part of the price premium associated with SAF, but the replicability in other regions may not yet be assured. ABRA Group’s Whittaker cautioned that corporate demand for such certificates remains less developed in parts of Latin America. The airline group is instead working with Sumitomo on a proposed mechanism under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement that would allow Japanese buyers to purchase emissions-reduction credits associated with SAF produced and used in Brazil.
The ‘last mile’ and ‘why SAF price is getting higher’
Cathay’s Ghanem also questioned why airlines could not more readily purchase SAF themselves, rather than relying on incumbent fuel suppliers. Airport fuel infrastructure remains concentrated among a small number of established operators, limiting airlines' ability to negotiate directly with producers. A 2024 IATA study found that 59% of 123 major airports surveyed worldwide had some form of restricted access to fuel infrastructure).
Providing a glimpse into a potentially better model, American Airlines’ Mathis noted that pipeline capacity into US airports can be reserved by new shippers. “So basically anybody can come in, become a new shipper, and go to the airport.” “[At the recent] IATA Energy Forum in Paris [IATA members] couldn't get any oil companies to go on stage […] so it's telling something.”
IAG's Olan Ryan suggested that airlines seeking to procure SAF directly might need to “vertically integrate their logistics access” or explore tripartite arrangements with existing fuel suppliers. Such arrangements could give airlines “more negotiating power”, he argued, adding that IAG was discussing the issue of SAF self-supply with the UK government.
Heathrow's carbon policy manager, Juliana Scavuzzi, also identified “access to the last mile to the airport” as a particular concern, as SAF production becomes increasingly decentralised.
The Ishka Airfinance View
Europe's SAF mandates are driving consumption, but airlines are raising concerns about compliance charges and their ability to purchase fuel independently of established suppliers. In the meantime, Cathay Pacific's experience attests to how European compliance-related pricing expectations are also influencing voluntary SAF procurement abroad.
Embracing SAF certificate trading through Book and Claim could improve procurement flexibility, However, as the European Commission's policy officer Jo Dardenne cautioned, “[Book and Claim] may help, [but] it's not the silver bullet” that could end fuel infrastructure oligopolies.
An EASA officer at the event noted that the agency is working on a technical study, due by year-end, examining whether “targeted book and claim elements” could improve SAF documentation and airlines' access to alternative suppliers in Europe. Another development to watch will be the Commission's 2027 ReFuelEU Aviation review. In a February 2025 report, the Commission identified airports where “the market structure and the position of aviation fuel suppliers may have an impact on the price and availability of SAF” as an area for further examination.